Pages

Monday, 1 October 2012

Introduction to M. D. Nalapat's Anthology 'Indutva' (1999)

In 1999, Har-Anand published Indutva an anthology of MD Nalapat's 1990s columns from the Times of India. The individual columns are posted here, in 1998 and 1999 of the blog archive, though the exact dates of publication are uncertain. This is an introduction to the anthology. 


Conventional wisdom has it that India was colonised for a 
millennium, from the time when Mahmud Ghori finally succeeded 
in defeating Prithviraj Chauhan and establishing Mughal rule on 
the subcontinental soil. In fact, while formally the country was
ruled by its own inhabitants before then, the fact is that even 
before the Mughals, the majority of the population was living as
subject. The caste system in India was a form of social oppression 
that was the equal of colonial rule. In such a system, those  
belonging to the "lower castes" had no incentive to help the
"forward castes" battle the invader. For them, rule by the 
Mughals meant only the exchange of one form of subjugation by
another. 

Inequality is a fact of existence. Differences in attributes and 
incomes will be present in any society. However, this is not the
same as oppression, whereby the underprivileged are denied a 
reasonable chance to improve their condition. Where pre-Mughal  
India failed was in perpetuating a system with few safety valves; 
a system in which the "lower orders" got their rank determined 
from birth, and consequently had no opportunity to escape. It is 
I ironic that those who (correctly) point to the exploitation of 
India's colonial masters over a millennium are mostly silent on 
the social conditions that fragmented subcontinental society, and
fatally weakened its defensive capabilities.

The defeat of Prithviraj Chauhan came out of two fundamental 
causes. First, the fragmentation of his social milieu, which 
resulted in less than 10% of his subjects forming the pool from 
which his officer cadre got created. As a consequence, the
motivation of the rest would have been weak, in that they were
not fighting for the continuation of their liberty, but to preserve
the privileges of the ruling easiest They themselves were given
no freedoms under such a system. 

The other reason for the failure to resist the invasion was the
defensive mindset of the subcontinent’s rulers. Rather than wait
passively for each invasion by the persistent Ghori, Chauhan
needed to mobilize other rulers in the region and launch a
surprise attack on the base areas of the invaders. Such a move
may have changed the course of India’s history, and pushed the
subcontinent’s footprint further westwards. However, this
fatalistic mindset ensured that any such strategy was not tried.
Indeed, even today such an approach holds sway, with the result
that national security gets compromised.

If the schism was between the "forwards" and the "backwards"
during the battle against the Mughals, it became a Hindu-
Muslim one during the struggle against the British. While
condemning Mohammed Ali Jinnah for vivisecting the
subcontinent, many of our historians ignore the mistakes made
by the then Congress leadership in dealing with Jinnah, and
more broadly with the communal question. From giving oxygen
to the fanatic Khilafat movement to adopting a song that had 
negative connotations in the Muslim mind, Congress leaders
alternately pandered to and then condemned the rise of
exclusivism in the subcontinent’s second largest religious group.  
The term "Nationalist Muslim" became a term of abuse, almost
as much as the expression "Hindu Nationalist” is politically 
incorrect today.

Despite its size and resilience, India took much longer to
secure its freedom than it should, Sometime during the interwar
period, the, country ought to have been given Dominion Status,
placing it on par with Canada or Australia. That never happened,
partly because of Colonel Blimps in Britain, but also because of 
the tactical errors made by the Congress leadership in dealing
with both British as well as international opinion, crucially in the
United States. This strengthened those who regarded Hindus as
"shifty" and gravitated towards the pinstriped Jinnah, who
made no secret of his support to the British war effort;

There is the story of a soldier who was ordered to bear a
hundred lashes or eat a kilo of salt as punishment. He first took
a bit of the salt, and then asked for the lashes. After getting a few,
he changed his mind and asked for the salt instead. Finally, he 
ended up absorbing both the punishments. This was the Congress
attitude during much of the 1930s, when the party appeared to
have two heads, both giving contradictory orders. There would 
be a bout of attempted reconciliation with the British, followed 
by a violent lunge in the opposite direction. Indian historians
have either not cared — or not dared — to analyse such
dissonances, though a consensus is emerging that the core of the
aggressive lobby was lawaharlal Nehru. By succumbing to his
line, the Congress got distanced from both the British and Jinnah, 
leading to a 'delay in self-rule and to the Partition. 

Many of those active in the freedom struggle behaved as
though their objective was the securing of ministerial berths for
themselves, no matter what consequences these entailed for the 
country. Instead, had their subliminal — as distinct from the  
stated — objective been freedom and prosperity for the 
subcontinent’s population, they would have factored in the
ground realities while working out their strategies. These would
have argued in favour of policies that made the British
establishment accept the inevitability of a free India, and reassured 
Jinnah’s significant constituency that they would be co-equal
sharers of power in a united country. However, as in many other
instances in the past, emotion took precedence over reason. 
Glands, in other words, were more decisive in policy formulation  
than brains. 

Despite partition, the residue that calls itself the Republic of 
India is on track to emerge as a great power early in the next
century, and a superpower thereafter. Had vivisection been 
avoided in 1947, such a process may already have taken place.
Hopefully the lessons of the past will get internalised, and
policies crafted that will ensure a subcontinental common market
embracing Sri Lanka, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Nepal, Myanmar, 
India, Bangla Desh, Bhutan and the Maldives. It is in the 
economic interest of India's neighbours to create a "Rupee Zone"
in which the Indian currency will be legal tender. This will
enable them to access Indian capital and markets to the extent 
needed to generate a reasonable rate of growth. Given the 
poverty in the region, this has to be 9% per year.

However, such policies can only get developed in an
environment where the past gets objectively analysed. There
should be no sacred cows in history. The fact is that India got
freedom ninety years after the War of Independence began in
1857. It got divided before this, first by the detachment of Sri
Lanka and Myanmar and later by the creation of Pakistan. Those  
strategic planners in the United Kingdom who hoped to hobble 
the residual India made an error. They assumed that India 
would be hostile to the West, and hence needed to be boxed in 
by the creation of "friendly" entities. Today, Myanmar at least
is no ally of the West, while Pakistan has become one of the
primary factories for the drugesterror lobby. It is only the 
continued development of India as a moderate democracy with
a liberal economic policy that can act as a counterweight to such 
adverse tendencies. Ironically, the countries that were put in the
role of "allies" have objectively become strategically hostile to 
Western interests, while the recalcitrant, India, is emerging as a 
friend. 

Like most processes, this too is not immediately visible. At 
present, New Delhi is at odds with the United States, Japan and
the European Union, all three of which seek to give Communist 
China a strategic monopoly in Asia. They clearly expect that the
chemistry of economic liberalisation in that ancient civilisation 
will generate unstoppable pressures for political reform, and the  
consequent toppling of the Communist regime. lust as the 1940s
sums of the UK strategic experts went wrong in South Asia, such 
doomsday views on the longevity (or lack of it) of the Communist 
Party of China are likely to be proved false. At least for the next  
three decades, the CPC is likely to continue to dominate China. 
And as the country expands in muscle, it can be expected to 
assert its role as the Middle Kingdom—the true centre of world
power, displacing the United States. 

China will have three thrust areas: the East Asian-ASEAN  
region, where it will challenge the US and Japan; Central Asia,
to provide an alternative to the Gulf for securing fossil fuels; and 
Siberia, which can effectively be colonised by the movement of 
Chinese populations to the region. South Asia is of relevance  
only because Beijing, since the 1950s help given to the Dalai  
Lama by the Nehru government, sees New Delhi as hostile to its  
integrity. Thus it seeks to contain India and defang it strategically, 
a task in which it has got enthusiastic cooperation from its future  
strategic rivals, Japan, the EU and the US. So long as Sino-Indian 
tension exists, there will be an undercurrent of instability in the  
region. A policy "based on realpolitik would aim for an 
accommodation with Beijing, and an informal sharing of 
pre-eminence in Asia, with China given primacy in the South and
North China seas, and India in the Indian Ocean area. Japan,
ASEAN and Korea would over time develop as neutral between 
China and the United States, the two likely contenders in the
next century.

The United States appears to have adopted the earlier mission
of the European powers, to "civilize" the globe. Thus it is 
pushing selectively for democracy, in countries that are not
entirely within its strategic grasp. India can have no such
pretensions to such a role. For at least the next half-century, its 
attention will need to be expended on economic problems. The
core need will be to generate a growth rate of at least 9%. Ideally,
it should touch 12%. This alone can lift the Indian people from
poverty within a reasonable life span, i.e., within their lifetimes. 

Economic growth is a function not just of economic, but also
social and security policies. To ensure an internal and external 
environment for growth, India needs:
(a) a moderate social climate at home, so that energies do not
get dissipated on fratricidal conflicts, but get focused on the core
issue of growth.
(b) friendly relations with the emergent power centres, 
principally the United States, followed by China and the European 
Union. India already has good relations with Russia.
(c) improving ties with the emerging power centres, the Arab
states, Japan, the CIS, Brazil and ASEAN.
(d) rational economic policies, that promote investment, both
foreign and domestic. This will include the replacement of
several of the existing laws with legislation that does not regard
productive activity as a crime, and measures to block this as
worthy of support.
(e) a "porcupine quill" that will defend against external
attempts at destabilisation, and also demoralize likely internal 
agents of such forces. This means technological (rather than
quantitative) parity with the other great powers in the strategic 
field.

Most countries, in common with individuals, use the past as
the benchmark to evaluate the present. This leads to the
formulation of policy that has no potency in an environment that
has changed dramatically. A case in point is the "anti-foreigner"
campaign, that every once in a while erupts into demonstrations
against soft drinks or chicken outlets. These are based on the 
same feelings of inferiority that German skinheads have when 
they attack immigrants who are more accomplished than they
themselves can ever hope to be. India’s skinheads are a useful
ally to agencies such as Pakistan’s Inter-Services Intelligence,
which share with them the common goal of preventing foreign
investment in India. 

Stalin once characterised Social Democracy and Nazism as
"Twins, not Antipodes". In the process, he made the German
communists take on the moderates with an equal or greater
virulence than that shown to Hitler”s followers. Partly as a 
consequence, the Nazis came to power in 1933. Very soon, they
showed how different they were from the Social Democrats, by 
destroying the structures of the Communist Party in Germany. 
By equating the foreign businessman with the security analyst
who seeks to lock India into permanent inferiority, many 
"nationalist” elements are in effect playing a supporting role to
those groups that seek to restrict India to its current marginal 
role.

Not just the foreign businessman, but the external societies 
and polity can be harnessed as allies in the task of accelerating 
the development process. With its western-influenced systems   
and language skills, India can attract a minimum of 
USD 30 billion a year in foreign investment. This is apart from the 
USD 10 billion that it can earn through tourism. To ensure such an 
outcome,the hitherto prevalent image of a tolerant society needs 
to be protected. This implies firm action against those who seek  
to hurt those belonging to other faiths. Just as the Plague Scare 
cost India hugely in terms of lost investment, the current  
Intolerance Scare may prove even more damaging. 

It is not just most Indians who are moderate, but the  
overwhelming majority of holy men, of whatever faiths. However, 
this group has perforce become a ’silent’ one, because few in the  
media care to reflect their beliefs. It is only the violent and 
bigoted few who get exposure in both the print as well as the  
electronic media. Had these made the (moderate) effort of  
locating those who believe rather than dismiss the country’s  
tradition of tolerance, it would have helped to shore up such a 
spirit from the attack of the extremists. 

Pakistan is an example of where the future will lead for India,
if the bigots continue their advance. Even before Partition, the
populations of the regions now comprising that country were
much less fanatic than their co-religionists in regions such as
what is now Uttar Pradesh and Bihar. It is from these regions that
the separatist movement was provided with oxygen. Today,
sadly, even in Pakistan Punjab the fanatics are visibly dominant.
The old traditions of tolerance that characterised the subcontinent
are disappearing from that country. It is an onward march to
chaos. Should current societal trends continue in that country,
there will inevitably be fresh partitions on the 1971 model. Only
the revival of moderation can preserve Pakistan from
disintegration.

Those who were complacent about the "impossibility" of
India ever following the Pakistan example need to redo their
sums in the face of current developments. Those who bandish
the trishul and burn Christian churches, or those who condemn
Muslims, are playing the precise game of religious polarization
that Jinnah intended for the subcontinent. Hindutva has become
the ally of the ISI. It needs to be replaced by Indutva.

Religious differences are only name-deep. What counts are the
bonds of geography, history and culture that link one Indian to
another, indeed that link all inhabitants of the subcontinent.
After centuries of conflict, if Europe moved towards a common
market, why not Sri Lanka, the Maldives, Bhutan, Bangla Desh,
India, Myanmar, Pakistan, Afghanistan and Nepal? What needs
to be done is to create a Rupee Bloc in this group of countries,
in which a single currency will get accepted as legal tender, at
least for external transactions. This will fuel the development of
industries and services that would otherwise be constrained by
shortages of "hard" currencies. India can take the initiative in
getting other neighbours to follow the example of Nepal in
making the Indian rupee legal tender within the Kingdom. There
is no need to wait for consensus solutions. It is better to adopt
a one-by-one approach, so that finally the holdouts realize that
the costs to them of obstinacy are too significant to justify.

India needs to be generous to the neighbours detailed above,
except in the sphere of national security, where concessions have
to be avoided. There needs to be a clear delineation between
national security and other spheres, so that a double-track policy
gets followed: concessions on economic and social interaction, 
but a clear India-first approach on security issues. For example,  
India can make transit concessions to Nepal, but none on  
Kalapani (which appears to be a Chinese demand put through 
the Nepal government). India can sanction the import of Pakistani 
raw materials and produce, without budging on its consistent 
stand that the Kashmir accession is a closed chapter, and that 
those who believe otherwise should focus their attentions not on  
New Delhi, but on the Mountbatten estate. 

Despite a population of nearly a billion, India is usually at the
bottom of the table in sports events. This indicates the national
disease of not identifying and then utilising our potential. A 
well-conducted search could uncover hundreds of putative 
world champions, who could then be groomed to compete. A  
country that can financially sustain a horde of bureaucrats that 
in total are larger than the entire defence forces of the top ten 
military powers, can surely sustain a few hundred athletes for 
the decade or two that it needs to get them to bring in the 
international medals. Not just the government, but even the 
private sector is guilty of doing little to uncover sports talent.
However, this field is just one of the several in which 
individuals with potential fail to get identified and nurtured. If  
the country is today developing a small army of software  
professionals, the credit goes to the hundreds of thousands of  
individuals who developed their skills, rather than to any  
organized effort. Indeed, by pricing communications beyond the  
reach of the bulk of the population, official policy is retarding me  
growth of the software industry.

Another example of suicidal policies is in education. The 
country has the brain power to man dozens of technical institutes,  
that can attract students from all over the world. If just 25% of 
the seats in each such institution can be reserved for overseas 
students (at international market rates), then 50% can be occupied  
by Indian students who would pay much lower fees. 25% can be 
reserved for the economically underprivileged, who would pay  
no fees. In this manner, overseas students will subsidize the  
education of locals. However,  a move that would certainly 
have delighted the hundreds of foreign institutions that are 
earning millions through Indian students, the proportion of  
foreign students eligible for admission in Indian institutions has
been reduced further from an already low 15% granted by the 
Supreme Court.  

Kerala is an example of how "socialist" policies in effect harm 
the interests of the poor. Most medical and engineering colleges
in the state are government-financed, which means that they are  
run through indirect taxes collected from the poor. However, 
few such individuals have the good fortune to actually study in
such institutions. Most of those admitted come from better-off 
families who can afford good education. Thus, in Kerala the poor
pay for the education of the rich. On the contrary, if private
medical and engineering colleges get freely sanctioned, these can
charge high fees to those who can afford to pay, while reserving 
25% of their seats to the poor at zero fees. Through such a 
scheme, the rich would pay for the education of the poor, which  
is the way it should be. However, in India, the "Socialist" pattern 
introduced by members of the elite in the country ensures that 
the poor subsidies the education of the better-off. 

Defence is another sector that could have been used to  
generate funds for itself, and that too without the sale of lethal 
weapons. This could have been possible by the setting up of  
institutes that can train foreign nationals, especially in the 
maritime field. The country has a pool of serving and retired  
armed forces officer who could easily staff such centres, if only 
the needed permissions were given. It is not a coincidence that  
the country is doing very well in precisely those sectors
software and jewellery export are examples—where the 
government has not paid much attention. However, India’s 
software exports are rising so rapidly that it will not be long 
before competitors abroad reach to policy circles in Delhi to set 
up roadblocks. As decision-taking in several key ministries has 
shown, many would obey alien diktats if this could guarantee 
them a sinecure in an international organisation.

Mir Jafar and Raja Jaichand, not to speak of the princes who
helped Mahmud Ghori against Prithviraj Chauhan, have
illustrated the ease with which Indians can be recruited to fight
against the interests of their own country. The reason for this is 
not that individuals from the subcontinent are particularly
treasonous or venal, but that they have very little confidence in
the countries of their birth or citizenship, and consequently are
on offer to a good Bidder. Had there been a stronger conviction   
that India, together with its South Asian partners, would emerge 
as a major factor in international politics, greater resistance   
would have been there to attempts at subornation. It is interesting   
to note that while nationals of countries such as the United   
States, Japan, Germany or France aggressively promote their  
national interests in international agencies, nationals of India are   
usually known for the reverse, adopting equidistance if not  
hostility to their country’s projects.  

Unlike other countries, that lobby to shoehorn their nationals 
into key slots in international bodies, the bureaucracy in India 
routinely shoots down requests for even elected representatives  
to travel abroad to attend conferences or discussions. As a result, 
decisions that impact on Indian interests get taken in absentia. In 
particular, those from the "higher" central administrative services 
work to reserve such slots for themselves rather than be given to
professional experts and members of the armed forces. Clearly,
the dominance of caste as a concept is still prevalent while taking
decisions in India. Sadly, many of the backers of "Hindutva" see 
Christians or Muslims as the gravest threat to Hindu society,  
when in fact the maximum harm has come from the artificial 
creation of barriers between one believer and the other. Unless 
such pernicious practices are eliminated, Hindus will continue to 
drift away from the religion, however many missionaries and 
their children/get burnt by alleged practitioners of a religion that  
venerates tolerance and non-violence. 

In fact, the fundamentals of Sanatan Dharma would be better 
served if its supporters accepted the reality that all roads lead to 
the same goal, and that India regards all her children as being 
equal, no matter what their faith. Indeed, what needs to be done  
are gestures that eliminate the differences. For example, the 
concept of the Hindu Undivided Family in taxation can be
replaced by the Indian Undivided Family, thus ensuring that  
there is no discrimination against others. Secondly, the concept
of "minority" should be exercised in a district-wise context, so  
that those districts where non-Hindus form a majority should see  
the Hindus having the same- rights as religious minorities enjoy  
in the places where Hindus form the majority. Also, linguistic 
minorities should be treated on par with other minorities in each  
district, and given the same privileges. 

In short, Indutva implies the acceptance of revised social 
norms, that conform to age-old tenets rather than to the centuries
of conflict that this country has witnessed. Such a process is
taking place in the Christian countries of Europe and North 
America. Where formerly the building of temples or the 
conversion to Hinduism was actively opposed by local  
communities, today the subculture is accepting much more of  
such deviations from the norm. A similar tolerance needs to take  
root in India. 

India's traditions and culture need to form linkages with  
neighbouring areas, not just within South Asia but across the 
much wider footprint that is her hinterland. This comprises the  
Gulf, the CIS states, the Indian Ocean Rim states and ASEAN. In  
each of these zones, efforts need to be made to exchange cultural  
impulses, such as films, dance and music. The growth of television 
across this region has made such a prospect feasible. What is 
lacking is the will among the countries involved to interchange 
their cultural matrices with each other rather than mostly from 
their former colonial masters. 

Such an endogenous interchange does not mean the rejection
of other streams. In fact, India for example needs to build upon 
the few benefits of colonial rule, the primary among which was  
the spread of the international link language, English. Rather
than restrict knowledge of this language to the economic elite, 
efforts need to be made to spread it lower down, so that
manpower in this country can access markets where the
knowledge of an international language is essential.

By not following through the actual effects of the policies that 
get introduced in the name of the poor, successive governments 
in India have created structures that inhibit rather than promote
upward mobility. An example is education in English. Many 
state governments have given low emphasis to education in the
international link language, thus giving a severe handicap to
those unable to afford private education. Why should the state
sector-whether it be in hospitals or schools or industrial units
be the worst in quality while simultaneously the most expensive 
to maintain? This question hardly appears to agitate the political  
mind, which continues to believe in myths and stereotypes. 

One such myth is the belief that utilisation of the official media
for a frankly political purpose will serve the interests of those
who are doing so. In fact, much of such propaganda is so crude    
that it puts off the voter, as has been demonstrated in election    
after election. However, as yet such empirical evidence has not   
led to the professionalisation of the official media, notably 
Doordarshan. If the private channels can get hundreds of crores 
of rupees of advertisements, Doordarshan—with its much larger    
audience—should be able to rake in thousands of crores of 
rupees. Sadly, it does not.

Pride is unfashionable. And yet, it is essential if individuals 
are to take the trouble of changing their fates. It is not just the 
penalties but the sense of pride in the city-state that prevents 
Singaporeans from dirtying their surroundings in the way that 
Indians do. Were those who fling refuse out of their homes onto 
the roads confident about the standing of the country in which 
the road is situated, there may have been hesitation at littering  
it. Unfortunately, neither the official nor the private media create  
an ambience of confidence in the country, its people and its  
future. When the US, Japan and a few other powers eager to  
retain their monopoly of power imposed sanctions on India, 
 there was a collective howl in the national press especially the  
economic newspapers — about how the sanctions would create    
a “meltdown" in the economy. For weeks the front pages got  
filled with doomsayers, with the optimists being dismissed as   
idiots. Only after a year had passed, and the Indian economy   
continued to grow stably, did external commentators admit that 
sanctions had Shot worked. This refrain was immediately picked 
up by the same domestic pundits who had - a scant year ago -  
warned of collapse thanks to sanctions. 

Confidence is part of the process of development, and the 
Indian media have worked hard to ensure that Nehru’s vision 
gets realized, and India follows the USSR into oblivion. However,
such negativism is becoming hard to sustain these days. Every  
week, international newspapers carry reports about Indians who 
have succeeded in the world outside. That India, with its  
civilisation and its heritage, carries within it the best seed in the 
world is a truism for believers in Indutva. Now, thanks to  
software professionals and indeed professionals in general, this 
fact is slowly becoming apparent to a world that had only seen
Indians through the misery and poverty of India. A misery   
created by colonial rule that ended only in 1991, when a genuine 
Indian took office as Prime Minister and was able to rule for five
years. The Nehru family are European in all but nationality.
Indeed, many European nationals are closer to India "chemically"
than they are. Thus their rule was only an extension of the earlier
stints of Mughal-British raj. Small wonder that restrictions and
prohibitions multiplied, so that enterprise was made so difficult
as to be impossible for most.

Such a system is ideal for the crook. An office on the take
welcomes tighter rules, as each turn of the screw multiplies his
chances for loot. A finance minister who has only black money,
and who is in the company of others similarly placed, will have
no problem levying very high rates of tax, because she or he will 
never have to pay it. Only the honest taxpayer suffers under such
a system, as was the case during the Nehru era. Only during the
Chidambaram years were taxes cut to sensible levels, although
Yashwant Sinha - clearly to help his former brothers in the civil
service - has been trying to raise them again. If the economy is 
showing robustness despite wars and mismanagement, the credit
should go to the Chettiar from Tamil Nadu who gave Indians a
fair deal for the first time in a millennium. Manmohan Singh was
good to the foreigner, which is why he got lavish praise.
Chidambaram was beneficial to Indians, hence is regarded with
scorn. The limited internal liberalisation initiated during the
Narasimha Rao years proved much more decisive in sparking
growth much above the Nehru rate than the repeated cuts in
customs duties resorted to by Manmohan Singh. Sadly, this
domestic liberalisation is still proceeding at a fitful pace, as
witness the constraints to investment in infrastructure and
services. 

An example of the costs the Nehru system imposes on
enterprise is the journey of a truck as it meanders from Patiala
to Sriperumbudur. Most of the roads are narrow, thus slowing
down speed and helping shorten the life of the vehicle and its
driver. Every now and again there are checkpoints that slow
down the vehicle for hours, till money gets paid. Small wonder
that a 4000-kilometre journey takes four times longer in India 
than in even median economies. No surprise that interest costs
are three times more, and power twice as expensive. The only
advantage is squeezed out of the Indian work person, who toils
for a monthly package far below that secured by those in other
economies. Those historians who extol the virtues of India's first
set of leaders need to examine the relative position of India with
other Asian economies in 1947 and now. Relatively, rule since 
much of 1947 has been an even bigger disaster than during 
colonial times.

The solution is not to change, but to become more of ourselves.
Today the Indian is a composite of Vedic, Mughal and Western 
traditions, each fusing seamlessly into the other, as music and 
dance demonstrate. The solution lies not in Hindutva or in the 
turning away from religion that "secularist" purists demand.
The solution lies in Indutva.

Sunday, 30 September 2012

Mr Obama, free Bradley Manning, the authentic American hero (Sunday Guardian)

MADHAV NALAPAT
ROOTS OF POWER


People hold signs asking to free Bradley Manning during the LA Pride parade in West Hollywood in June. REUTERS
here are few people on earth nicer than citizens of the US of A. Similar to sojourns in India, those visiting the US usually return with affectionate tales of the courtesy and hospitality of Americans. They love life, and they love it when others do as well. Envy is not part of the American spirit, emulation is. However, there is an exception, a substantial one, and this is the tribe which collectively comprises the government of the United States. Public service in that country (a double misnomer, as is the case in most other locations across the globe) has the effect of shrivelling up an individual's reserves of generosity and openness, leaving in its wake a desiccated consciousness out to constrain and punish all those less than obsequiously respectful of those in positions of authority. Would that the airport manager in the movie Terminal were the exception. Across government offices all over the US and in that country's stations abroad, such a pedantic and unfeeling application of mechanical rules is the norm, with of course exceptions. Small wonder that most of the serious crimes in the US get committed by graduates of the world's most effective training school for anti-socials, US prisons. Add to that the fact that since the era of Richard Nixon, there has been a huge spurt in the prison population, because of the mandatory nature of sentencing for offences where a first-timer is almost never a threat to society, such as the use of marijuana, a substance that ought to be legalised the way alcohol has been in India except in parts of Kashmir and in the whole of Gujarat. Of course, once the offender passes through the prison system, it is a different story.
Unsurprisingly, for a person known to have a Europeanist view of the world, Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton never hesitates to give lectures on morality and political correctness, except when she is visiting the GCC and China. Even the self-advertised "largest democracy in the world" has been subjected — this time with ample justification — to verbal whiplashes, especially on the issue of freedom of speech. Another hobby of the lady is human rights. Syria's Bashar Assad is a constant target of Clintonian ire because of his unreasonable refusal to allow himself and his regime to be subjected to the same fate as met Muammar Gaddafi last year, when — according to some reports — a US spotter drone revealed his location to anti-Gaddafi fighters and a French commando squad participated in his final moments, no doubt in the cause of Liberte and Egalite.
A mistake is excusable, but not if it gets repeated. First in Libya and now in Syria, weapons and cash are being given to fanatics who will next attack their benefactors, as indeed they recently did in Benghazi. The capacity of the members of NATO to delude themselves is huge, for a few paid demonstrations by groups of unemployed youths has been taken by BBC, CNN and Al Jazeera as evidence that "the Libyan people are against the killers" of the martyred Stevens. And now Syria is being torn apart. The worry is that this virus could before long spread to parts of the GCC as well, thereby severely affecting global stability. The Arab world needs to resolve its internal differences sans external interference, if stability is ever to return. But for this to happen, there needs to be a single standard of praise and blame.
In that context, blowing away the cloak of secrecy from operations that have led to the deaths of countless innocent lives would be the warp and woof of a Nobel Prize nomination, were it to take place in Syria, Iran or another of the Shia Crescent states so disliked by NATO. However, when a young and idealistic US soldier, Bradley Manning, allegedly transferred data on wartime atrocities by US troops to Julian Assange, he was sent to prison in 2010 in a way that makes a mockery of US claims to be a society that lives by the rule of law. In what way is the exposure of a crime itself a crime? Manning acted from motives very different from that which motivate the many who have collectively donated $70 bn to the Clinton Global Initiative, earning not a cent from his disclosures. Like Daniel Ellsworth before him, who leaked the Pentagon Papers, Manning is an authentic American hero. Rather than him being in prison, it ought to be the murderous pilots outed by him who ought to have lost their liberty. Freedom of speech and human rights ought not to stop at the shores of the US. President Obama, show that this is not so by releasing Bradley Manning now.

Friday, 28 September 2012

Tsai visit boosts India-Taiwan ties (PO)

By M D Nalapat


Although very much smaller in size and population, Taiwan has double the foreign exchange reserves and foreign trade of India.Jawaharlal Nehru adopted a policy of siding with the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and its newly-established Peoples Republic of China (PRC) rather than the Kuomintang (KMT),which shifted to Taiwan in 1949.That was the first of many diplomatic moves that Nehru made to separate from the US the country whose foreign policy he single-handedly controlled since 1947,India.Because of his admiration for the USSR and its system of centralised planning (which Nehru - again without consultations with other individuals in the Congress Party or the government - adopted), the then Prime Minister of India fashioned a diplomatic posture that was usually on the side of Moscow rather than Washington. Certainly the fact that President Harry Truman reversed the anti-colonial policy of Franklin Roosevelt and aligned Washington firmly with European colonial powers helped propel India away from the US. However,it was equally true that such ideals as liberty and democracy were often cast aside by Nehru,especially when the USSR invaded Hungary in 1957 and, earlier, had in effect converted several countries in Eastern Europe into colonies of Moscow.

Nehru’s spurning of the KMT showed a lack of gratitude on his part.KMT supremo Chiang Kai-shek and his exquisite spouse Soong Mei-ling had strongly supported freedom for India at every meeting they had with the irascible and wholly racist Prime Minister of the United Kingdom,Winston Churchill.The strong support given to the freedom movement by the KMT was a source of considerable annoyance to Churchill,who regarded it as just that his nation should rule over India in perpetuity.However,Chiang’s backing for Indian independence was forgotten by Nehru,who rejected his Taipei-based government to become one of the first three countries to recognize the PRC. After that,relations between Taiwan and India shrank to nothing, a state of affairs which continued till the mid-1990s,when Prime Minister P V Narasimha Rao established formal ties with both Taiwan as well as Israel.

Rao focused on the economy, which for the first time since 1947 was to an extent freed of the Soviet-style constraints that had bound it since Nehru’s time,thereby condemning the economy to a measly rate of growth less than half that of Pakistan at the time. He saw that Taiwan had become a trading giant,rich in capital and in technology,and wanted the Indian economy to get the benefit of that. Encouraged by a small and informal group of advisors, Prime Minister Rao overrode opposition from within the government to establish ties with Taiwan.

Since then,these have grown considerably,such that both sides now issue visas to each other,and have signed a Double Taxation (Avoidance) Agreement. By 2013,it is expected that an India-Taiwan Free Trade Agreement will get signed,complementing the free trade agreement that Taipei signed with Beijing in 2008,and which brought several advantages to Taiwan. While it was the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) regime in Taipei (2000-2008) that first gave a boost to “IT” (India-Taiwan relations), the successor regime led by the KMT leader Ma Ying-jeou has carried forward this momentum. Indeed, Ma made a very successful visit to India less than a year before being elected President of Taiwan in 2008 In democracies,opposition parties are as important as ruling parties.Which is why it has been a handicap that the Manmohan Singh government lacked the courage to welcome DPP leader Tsai Ing-wen to India for four years,because of fear that Beijing would react negatively.

Although many of her close advisors have visited India several times,yet the Manmohan Singh government kept Madame Tsai from coming to India.Only this month,now that she has relinquished the post of DPP Chairperson and conceded the Presidential election to incumbent Ma Ying-jeou, has South Block discovered enough reserves of courage to agree to a visit by Madame Tsai. Clearly,the odour of the USSR-hugging past still hangs heavy over the Government of India, so that it sees nothing incongruous in keeping at bay the leader of one of the two main parties in a full-fledged democracy that is rapidly expanding its commercial relations with India.

Even though a visa was finally issued to the DPP leader (who is likely to contest again for the Presidency of Taiwan in 2016,and this time emerge successful), it is a shameful fact that the eminent statesperson was received on September 19 at Delhi airport only by the Taiwan Representative in India rather than by a dignitary of the Ministry of External Affairs,as she ought to have been Fortunately,Tsai Ing-wen is a homespun individual,who has little use for diplomatic niceties.Indeed,she travelled by train from Delhi to Mumbai on September 23,rather than go by air the way all - repeat all - other international political notables have. While in Mumbai,Madame Tsai stayed in an unpretentious but quality hotel,the Ambassador,and could frequently be seen walking down the streets of Mumbai with other members of her delegation.She has set an example in simple conduct that few international leaders - or their domestic counterparts - follow.

The long-delayed visit of the charismatic DPP leader Tsai Ing-wen to India is evidence of the close ties between India andTaiwan.It would be safe to predict that in the future,many Taiwanese companies and many,many Taiwanese tourists will come to India. Shared business and cultural interests bind Taipei and Delhi together, in a way that does not at all go against the interests of Taiwan’s giant neighbour,China,a country which has the potential to emerge as a close strategic partner of India during the next five years. Analysts expect that Xi Jinping,the new Chinese leader will within a year make a visit to India,his first ever,so that the two countries better tap the immense synergies they possess.
http://pakobserver.net/detailnews.asp?id=175692

Monday, 24 September 2012

Carriergate: $3 bn for a floating junkyard that refuses to sail (Sunday Guardian)

MADHAV NALAPAT
ROOTS OF POWER


Admiral Gorshkov, a Soviet-era aircraft carrier that was bought by India, is anchored at the Sevmash factory in Severodvinsk. REUTERS
here has to be weighty reasons why the entire defence establishment in India, including its political top tier, has been so enthusiastic about buying a mothballed Russian aircraft carrier, the "Baku" (since renamed "Admiral Gorshkov") for a price of $3 billion and counting. Some months ago, this columnist had visited Tianjin in China, where he saw another junked aircraft carrier, which had been converted into a floating museum by the Chinese authorities, in order to educate the public about the importance and configuration of a carrier. Although the exact cost of buying the vessel was not revealed, it was less than 5% of what the Indian taxpayer is paying for the "Baku", now renamed "Vikramaditya". Operational records of this vessel reveal that it was deemed seaworthy only five years after launch in 1982, because of the constant malfunctioning of several of its systems, including the core function of control. Ensuring that the ship safely sailed on the high seas, even for limited periods of time, proved so expensive that the Russian navy withdrew the ship from service after a measly ten years of operation. One factor behind the decision may have been its history of accidents, including an exploded boiler in 1994. It took another decade before the Russians could locate a buyer. That was India, where in 2004 the NDA agreed to purchase the vessel for a billion US dollars. Strangely, despite India getting such a poor bargain (in contrast to the Chinese), there were many smiles all across the defence and political establishment of Delhi at the purchase.
Such good humour multiplied after the UPA assumed office, and agreed to escalation after escalation of the cost. Presently, the Manmohan Singh government, whose finance ministers are so stingy about giving tax concessions to the middle class, has committed $3 billion in payouts to Moscow, a figure that is rising monthly. Given that the era of aircraft carriers has passed, unless to intimidate Tuvalu or Fiji, it would have made more sense to have spent that much money on the Integrated Guided Missile Development Programme of the DRDO, this time forcing that behemoth to partner with private Indian companies rather than keeping the entire production line within the state sector. A single missile costing less than $3 million is all that is needed to send "Vikramaditya" to where the Titanic has been resting for a century. As for comparisons between the missile capabilities of India and China, this would be akin to comparing the trusty Hindustan Ambassador with a Porsche. Hopefully, future wars will get fought only with countries such as Lesotho or Burkina Faso, for combat with either of our two neighbours (or with both acting in tandem) would severely test the composure even of the ever-hopeful Manmohan Singh. Given its record of operating extravagance, it is reasonably certain that once the "Vikramaditya" goes operational again, the Indian navy will become such a drain on the exchequer that even the Raid Raj of P. Chidambaram will not suffice to feed the maw of its immense — and expensive — white elephant.
Let it be admitted that this columnist has a preference, and this is for imitating the Pakistanis and sweet-talking the Americans into handing over more of their retired vessels, on the same lines as the USS Trenton was. This was sold to the Indian Navy in 2006 for $47 million, a tiny fraction of what was demanded for the "Baku". That Manmohan Singh enjoys the cosiest of relations with Washington is not entirely a secret. Had the Prime Minister spent less effort on tackling the soup served to him at President Obama's state banquet and focused on trying to get him to transfer another three or four mothballed carriers to India, even at a price of $200 million each, this would have been only what was originally demanded by Moscow for the "Baku". Just as the only way the Royal Navy was able to keep itself in business during 1939-41 was by the transfer of US ships to it, the only viable way in which the Indian Navy can emerge as a respectable double-ocean force in the next decade is by getting transferred US vessels to its fleet. When added to an expansion of the missile programme, this would have made Delhi the equal of any capital in Asia in terms of military power, given the pivotal importance of the navy (and the air force) in modern warfare. Instead, an unconscionable sum has been spent on a floating junkyard that refuses to sail, even after massive infusions of cash. In the hubbub over "Coalgate", the country is losing sight of "Carriergate".

Saturday, 22 September 2012

Video: Prof. Nalapat Interviewed on CCTV about Economic Reform in India (22 September 2012)

Japan must return to Asia (PO)

By M D Nalapat

After three centuries of defeat, the first major victory of an Asian power against a country which considered itself European was in 1905,when Admiral Togo Heihachiro sank the bulk of the Czarist (Russian) fleet off Tsushima. Across the continent, from Turkey to India to Vietnam, people who for centuries had been drained of their wealth and future by European powers rejoiced. In the victory of Japan, they saw a future where they themselves would get liberated. As indeed they were, including by armed conflict. A half-century after Tsushima, a cohort of ill-armed Vietnamese soldiers led by Marshal Vo Nguyen Giap defeated the French garrison at Dien Bien Phu, thereby emulating the Japanese defeat of the British, French and Dutch forces throughout South-east Asia. The Japanese wave was stopped only at the border of India, when largely Indian troops battled them to a standstill, only to continue to be treated as ninth-class and non-citizens by the very British crown whose fortunes they had rescued Despite the immense sacrifices made by Indian soldiers - over two million of them - during World War II, it was the French (with their much smaller contribution to the war effort) that Churchill indulged, placing Paris on the UN Security Council while refusing to give India any except the meanest role in the UNO. In the view of the Prime Minister who is celebrated in NATO capitals as being the “defender of democracy”, only those of a particular skin tone had the right to the benefits of democracy. The rest had to remain content as helots to the Master Race. Incidentally, this view of Winston Churchill was not different from that of Adolf Hitler, except that to the latter, much of Europe were helots as well.

To the racists in the chancelleries of London, Paris and elsewhere in Europe, it was a shock when Japanese troops swiftly overcame opposition from those who for centuries had cut through Asia with ease. Although the record of Japan in the countries it occupied was vile - none more so than in China, where unspeakable atrocities were committed - yet it must be acknowledged that the successes of Tokyo inspired freedom fighters throughout Asia, including in India, where Congress leader Subhas Chandra Bose decided to take help from Germany and Japan to fight the British. In retrospect, this was an unwise decision, as it drained away support for the Congress Party within the UK,thereby making it inevitable that Whitehall would accept the Jinnah-Churchill plan of dividing India. Although it is Pakistan that has got all the attention, the reality remains that Myanmar, Sri Lanka, Nepal, the Maldives and Afghanistan were also part of the British Raj,and that had the leaders of the subcontinent been more united and with a broader strategic vision, they would have held out for a united subcontinent that would immediately have emerged as a global force.

As it turned out, a divided subcontinent was created out of the departure of the British, thereby reversing one of the legacies of the Raj, which was to unify the ancient Subcontinent of India, which before the British took over, was a seething congeries of warring states Japan is one among the ancient civilisations of the world. The Japanese people are the inheritors of a grand tradition and noble culture. Which is why it has been a shock to see the way the culture of the country changed after its defeat in 1945. Since then, the establishment in Japan has tried to behave as though the country were located between Belgium and France, rather than in the eastern corner of Asia. It is comic to see the way some in that country wear tails and top hats, trying to pass off as Englishmen. Not surprisingly, several young women in Japan dye their hair in all sorts of colours, and are most happy when told that they look as though they were European. To be called that is the biggest compliment that can be paid to many.

Japanese, a people who seem to have turned their backs towards Asia even as they turn admiring faces towards Europe. That the peoples of Europe have given the world much of what is known as modern civilisation is a fact. The entire planet owes much to the immense brainpower of Europe. However, as Rudyard Kipling put it in somewhat more elegant prose, Asia is Asia and Europe is Europe. And historically, it is Asia that has been in the lead for most ofhistory, and will do so again It is time for Japan to re-enter Asia, and to turn its gaze towards its own continent. This means that Tokyo must strengthen its ties with countries such as India, while ensuring that it remains friendly to China and to Korea. A Japan re-integrated in Asia will provide the spark plug needed to ignite the continent, given the immense industry and skillsets of the Japanese people.

This time around, the focus has to be on avoiding war, rather than seeking out conflict. After having seen the collapse of European domination over the globe as a consequence of two world wars (in 1914-19 and 1939-45), Asia must accept the inevitability of peace. Tensions, such as those between Beijing and Tokyo, need to be damped down in the overall interest. Asian institutions need to get created, so as to follow the trajectory of Europe, which over the past sixty-seven years has avoided all except a few localised conflicts. The people of Japan need to look back at their own traditions and into their own roots, and accept that Japan must return to Asia.

http://pakobserver.net/detailnews.asp?id=174687

Sunday, 16 September 2012

The ‘New Taliban’ strike in Benghazi (Sunday Guardian)

MADHAV NALAPAT
ROOTS OF POWER

Christopher Stevens and three US embassy staff were killed on Tuesday, as they rushed away from a consulate building in Benghazi, stormed by Al Qaeda linked gunmen blaming America for a film insulting the Prophet Muhammad. REUTERS
here is something disarmingly boyish about middle-aged males active in policymaking in the countries that are members of NATO. They reach for the gun almost by instinct, by definition for the most noble of motives. If the purpose of stuffing opium down the throats of the Chinese a century ago was to help them forget the wretched nature of their existence, the aim of arming a motley group of extremists and mercenaries so that they can tear Syria apart is to promote the ideals of freedom and democracy. Certainly, the Syria that is likely to emerge from the cauldron into which it has been dropped by NATO will have the same elevated levels of democracy enjoyed by the populations of Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Bahrain and other countries much loved by NATO member-states for their commitment to values such as ensuring that women wear only the burqa or are forbidden to drive, or to travel on their own. Although this would be impossible to glean from looking at BBC or CNN, the reality is that post-"liberation" Libya has collapsed as a state. Even large cities such as Tripoli and Benghazi have been divided into neighbourhoods that are each run by local mafias. Anything goes in practically all parts of Libya, which is why it is well on the way to becoming another Taliban-run Afghanistan, a haven for extremists. Already, weapons from Gaddafi-era stockpiles are being sold or gifted to armed gangs across Africa and West Asia, thereby ensuring blood on the streets. Were the NATO bloc ever to suffer from the disease of honesty, they would agree that their intervention in Libya has destroyed the country in the same way as their assistance to anti-regime fighters in Syria is making that ancient land a hell.
In Doha, Istanbul and other cities located in countries that are working towards the replacement of Alawite rule in Syria with that of the Wahhabis, young toughs are open about the bounties they get from unknown benefactors for every Syrian official that they can prove to have been killed by them. Creating mayhem and indulging in murder on an industrial scale has become as lucrative a profession as being in the Mafia was in New York or Chicago in the 1920s. A crackpot "intellectual" in Paris, Bernard-Henri Levy, has given himself the credit for persuading the ever-excitable Nicolas Sarkozy to "save" the Libyan population by the innovative expedient of bombing them to bits. With the excitement found in all middle-aged boys, Sarkozy's plan of action was quickly adopted by David Cameron. And once these two got on board, so did Hillary Clinton. Together, they have created modern Libya, a country divided into several hundred principalities, in most of which ethnic cleansing and torture have become commonplace, although of course, unreported by NATO media eager to showcase Libya as a huge success for the mission to bring civilisation to the heathen.
J. Christopher Stevens was among the most ardent believers in this grand design. Within the US State Department, he was from the start tireless in advocating the arming, training and funding of the groups that collectively were let loose against Muammar Gaddafi. Neither Stevens nor anyone else bothered to look into the credentials of those they were helping. Had they just checked the emails these were sending to loved ones, they would have discovered that these "freedom fighters" had a visceral dislike of the free society that NATO was presumed to be bombing Libya for. They wanted a Wahhabi state to come up on the ruins of the authoritarian but secular Gaddafi construct, and said so in their emails and in their speeches. Although he knew Arabic, Chris Stevens was not listening to such chatter. There was in him — and in Cameron, Sarkozy, Clinton and others involved in the crusade against the hapless Gaddafi — a bloodlust that got satiated only when the defeated dictator was captured, sodomised and executed by a mob that reportedly included members of the Special Forces of a NATO member-state. He was tireless in ensuring that the fighters he loved with such passion were given the air support, diplomatic cover and resources to convert Libya into the chaos which passes for a country today.
Stevens was as much a benefactor of Libya's New Taliban as Robin Raphel was of the original Taliban in the 1990s. Hence his neglect of security, his confidence that his 2011 help to those now holding bits and pieces of Libya to ransom would ensure his protection. Unfortunately for him, he was wrong. The New Taliban have announced their advent in the same way as the elements which in time made up the Old Taliban did in the past, by killing a US ambassador. In his last moments, Ambassador Stevens must have been wishing that he had failed in 2011, and that Muammar Gaddafi still ran Libya. Had that been the case, the luckless US diplomat would still be alive.