Pages

Sunday, 14 July 2013

China Army hawks seek to sabotage peace with Delhi (Sunday Guardian)

MADHAV NALAPAT  Beijing | 13th Jul 2013
China's President Xi Jinping shakes hands with China's Premier Li Keqiang (L)
n a repeat of history, China's People's Liberation Army (PLA) is implementing the same "forward policy" initiated by Jawaharlal Nehru in 1960, which directly led to the 1962 conflict. This policy was adopted despite opposition from Chief of Army Staff General Kodendera Thimayya, who understood the risks involved in such adventurism and therefore lost the favour of both Nehru as well as then Defence Minister V.K. Krishna Menon. Today in China, the situation is reversed, in that it is a section of the military leadership in China that is pushing the envelope on India, even as the political leadership has made better ties with India one of the top priorities of the new administration. According to those following developments in Beijing, the PLA version of the old "forward policy" has been implemented since 2002, the year when tensions were high on the India-Pakistan border because of the terror attack on Indian Parliament the previous year. By now, infrastructure and communications on the Chinese side of the border have been improved to a level which would enable forces to move to forward positions within days of an order to do so. The Indian side has been slow to react to such activity, with infrastructure starting to get modernised in earnest only by 2010. It is this reaction to the PLA build-up, which has annoyed a section of the PLA leadership, leading them to intensify their probes into territory held by India, as well as the "creep" towards the Chinese claim line.
Defence Minister A.K. Antony was able to win an agreement last week from his Chinese counterpart to recognise that lack of tranquillity on the border will have an effect on the overall relationship. This has been a reversal of the post-2002 position of Beijing, which is that border issues should be kept to one side even while the commercial relationship ballooned, a politically unfeasible option for Team Manmohan. As a consequence, the 17 June Chumar incident, when an observation camera on the Indian side, which recorded nearby PLA movements, was taken away by Chinese soldiers, was quickly settled by the camera being returned. Both President Xi Jinping and Premier Li Keqiang have made good relations with India a priority. However, they are facing opposition from remnants of the Jiang Zemin faction, which regards India as a low priority. The Jiang faction has enriched itself through involvement in multiple businesses and is under pressure from the anti-corruption campaign being carried out by President Xi and Premier Li.
{
Both President Xi Jinping and Premier Li Keqiang have made good relations with India a priority. However, they are facing opposition from the hawks in the People’s Liberation Army.
According to a Beijing-based observer of the Chinese political scene, "There are elements who would like to create tension with foreign powers so as to divert the attention of the Chinese leadership from their focus on removing corruption." He claims that this group, which is close to former President Jiang Zemin (1993-2003), is behind the recent intrusions along the Sino-Indian border and the ratcheting up of tensions with Japan, the Philippines and Vietnam. "It was the personal intervention of President Xi and Premier Li that led to the swift resolution of the (Depsang) intrusion," whereas pro-Jiang elements wanted the standoff "to persist and ruin the atmospherics for Premier Li's India visit".
Any visitor to China will note the change in atmosphere after President Xi took office early in the year, with lavish entertainment getting replaced with much more sober functions. Those opposed to the clampdown on extravagance and graft are looking to create tensions between China and its neighbours so as to derail the Xi-Li anti-corruption movement. However, most observers say that the Xi-Li leadership duo is strong enough to ensure that another Depsang (or Chumar) gets avoided, and Sino-Indian commerce and tourism enter a boom period.

Sunday, 7 July 2013

Change in Egypt signals an excellent omen for the future (Sunday Guardian)

MADHAV NALAPAT
ROOTS OF POWER



Anti-Morsi protesters in Cairo on Friday. REUTERS
t is the western-educated "modern" leaders in non-western societies, who most pander to medieval impulses within their populations. Rajiv Gandhi was much more at home in Europe than he was in the villages of his constituency, and it is this lack of contact with his people that led him into errors such as the opening of the locks of the Babri Masjid and the Muslim Women's Bill. These twin decisions kicked off a fury of competitive communalism within the country that has yet to abate. In Saudi Arabia, it was the West-oriented King Fahd and his more Europeanised cousins, who allowed primitive elements in his society to assume a role that has only grown since then, and has made more reactionary not only Saudi Arabia but countries where the influence of its well-funded Wahhabi preachers is strong. Since 1979, the Al Sauds, despite their extensive contacts with the western world, have lavished money and attention on the more extreme of Wahhabi clerics, so much so that today, such elements have an influence far out of proportion to their actual following within the Muslim world, so much so that to many, Wahhabism is seen as identical to Islam when in fact the exclusivism and prejudice of the former is wholly contrary to the universal spirit of the latter. It took an Al Saud with very little exposure to westernisation to change course and steer Saudi Arabia back to the human qualities which best reflect the great faith that was revealed there. Visitors to Saudi Arabia ruled by King Abdullah can sense the change. For example, although theatres are still taboo, yet even large groups are allowed to view movies in private. King Abdullah has taken the lead in pushing for reconciliation between different faiths, even those that originated outside West Asia. While the interfaith conferences hosted by NGOs in Qatar confine themselves to Christianity, Judaism and Islam, those organised under the direction of King Abdullah have included Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists and Jains.
Mohammad Morsi was brought to power because of a popular movement that was largely secular. However, once in office, he sought to ensure that the Muslim Brotherhood was given a monopoly of top positions, while the traditional tolerance shown by officialdom towards Christians and the small Jewish community in Egypt got severely frayed in the Morsi period. The Brotherhood candidate had secured less than a quarter of the popular vote in the first round of the Presidential elections of 2012, but Morsi excluded from influence over policy the views of the three-fourths of his people who were not supporters of his movement.
Morsi sought to "do an Erdogan" in Egypt, except that the Turkish strongman has staggered his efforts at altering the secular fabric of his country over years, accelerating only this year, when he apparently believed himself to be unassailable. The other members of NATO, including the US, France and the UK, have a history of partiality towards Wahhabis. The leadership of the secular Turkish army was taken to pieces by Erdogan to appreciative nods from Paris, London and Washington, the same capitals which joined together to back General Kayani in his battle for influence against Asif Zardari, although the military in Pakistan is far from secular, seeing itself as essentially a religious army.
Now that the Egyptian military has ousted Mohammad Morsi, there has been much tut-tutting from the likes of Obama and Cameron, despite the fact that this move has brought Egypt back to the moderate path that Morsi and his party sought to free it from. President Obama follows Bill Clinton in his coddling of Wahhabi groups, as most recently evidenced by the nudge given to Qatar to fund a lavish quasi-embassy for the Taliban in Doha. Small wonder that he was clearly annoyed at the developments in Egypt. In contrast, King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia was prompt in giving his backing for the Egyptian military's move, a very significant in the context of the Muslim Brotherhood claiming to be the standard bearers of "political Islam".
The shameless use of religion and its symbols in their election propaganda is likely to ensure a somewhat hot reception for leaders of the Brotherhood in the hereafter. The use of religion in politics is repugnant to the spirit of democracy, and is traditionally a means through which corrupt and incompetent leaders seek to retain public support, by changing the terms of the discourse from performance to theology. Immediately after King Abdullah gave his nod to the ousting of Mohammad Morsi, the hereditary rulers of both the UAE as well as Qatar followed suit, although are considered to have been generous in their funding of Brotherhood offshoots throughout the region. Rather than bad news, the changeover in Egypt is an excellent omen for the future. It signifies that the Moderate Majority of the Muslim population is at last finding its voice and asserting its right to build a society in tune with humanistic rather than supremacist values.

http://www.sunday-guardian.com/analysis/change-in-egypt-signals-an-excellent-omen-for-the-future




Friday, 5 July 2013

India spurns GCC investment (PO)

M D Nalapat

Friday, July 05, 2013 - It used to be said of the Indian Civil Service during the days when the Union Jack flew all across India that the title was a “triple misnomer”, the ICS being neither Indian, nor civil, nor of any service. The same can be said of India’s intelligence agencies, who daily prove that such an adjective is misleading when applied to them. Indeed, such agencies in India have largely outsourced their decisions to the US and to major EU powers such as the UK and France.

The intelligence services of these powers are skilled in planting information that goes to their own commercial and political benefit, rather than ensure that the national interest of India gets upheld. An example is the flood of (mis) information about two locations on the globe that have the potential to be of immense significance to the economic future of India. These two regions are West Asia, principally the GCC but also including Iraq and Iran, and also East Asia, including China and Taiwan, besides Japan. The latter two, being allied to NATO, are seldom the focus of the disinformation campaign the way the GCC and China are. The intent of such reports is to ensure that the security and intelligence agencies in India work in a manner that feeds into the interests of NATO.

Each time a major investment opportunity rolls up that involves China or the GCC, leaks “from intelligence sources” begin to appear in the media, both print and television, pointing to unspecified “security risks” associated with such investment. Of course, all that the GCC or Chinese investor has to do is to route the money through a NATO-based financial enterprise. Contact with institutions such as Goldman Sachs immediately cleanses investment earlier regarded as suspect. In this way, almost all the investment into India comes from financial entities located within the NATO bloc, thereby fattening their balance sheets and creating a severe vulnerability in India. Each time such agencies sneeze, India catches a severe cold. Obsessed as they are with short-term profits, these entities indulge in speculation on a massive scale, and act in a manner that creates zigzags and instability in both commodities as well as equity markets. The reckless manner in which successive governments in India have handed over control of the economy to external players has resulted in a steady fall in the value of the rupee, to one-tenth the level that it had fifty years ago. This in an economy where imports exceed exports by a wide margin.

Those interested in a bright future for the Indian economy accept that a drive needs to be launched to ensure that investment into India from West Asia as well as East Asia increases manifold from the present pitiful levels. Yet this imperative has thus far been sabotaged by the way in which Indian intelligence agencies, acting on cues provided to them by external agencies whose reports are treated as wholly accurate, act covertly as well as openly to frequently block large-scaleinvestment from either the GCC or some parts of East Asia.

The latest casualty of such negativism has been Etihad Airlines, whose attempt to buy 24% of India’s Jet Airways has been stalled by a slew of allegations, most related to “security”. Certainly carriers from the EU and the US must be heaving a collective sigh of relief at the “Stop” sign shown to the Etihad-Jet deal, for the partnership would have cut sharply into the revenues into and out of India of carriers from France, the UK, the US and Germany, none of whom give airlines based in India the privileges and rights given to their own airlines by governments in India who are much more eager to protect certain overseas interests than to safeguard their own.

An example is the price of natural gas found within Indian offshore fields. It was only after an Indian company entered into a partnership with a NATO-based oil giant that the Manmohan Singh government moved with alacrity to double the price given to the amalgamated company for gas discovered well before the fresh investment came in. In fact, the price offered by the government is even more than the international price, whereas the concessions given to companies to discover gas in offshore Indian fields were meant to ensure that domestic gas remained cheaper than imports. Corporates in India know that the surest way to win the support of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and his political boss Sonia Gandhi is to enter into a partnership with a NATO-based entity. These are never accused of any “security risk”, which is not surprising, as several of the reports of such “risks” originate from within NATO-based agencies, both official and non-formal (such as NGOs) and get recycled by Indian agencies expert in leaking such titbits of misinformation to friendly mediapersons.

Had those managing the economy of India been independent of external players, the situation faced by the people would not have been as dire as it now is. Prices are rising as fast as the value of the rupee is falling. The natural resources of India have been handed over for derisory prices to a handful of well-connected players with external linkages, almost all of whom have promptly monetized their windfall by selling their stake at a huge profit. Domestic companies are suffering because of high interest rates and a slew of new regulations, most created for the purpose of extracting bribes. Although the stifling control of the central government over the economy was sought to be reduced from 1992 onwards, yet from 2004 (when Sonia-Manmohan took office) there has been a rollback of such reforms. By now, the economy has re-entered the atmosphere of the 1980s,when reforms were few and insignificant, and is retreating towards the 1970s,when the state was supreme and stifled all forms of enterprise.

The “achievement” of Sonia-Manmohan has been the return of India to the miserably low rate of growth (of less than 3%) of the 1950s,the 1960s and the 1970s.The vacillation and policy zigzags seen during the past seven years has resulted in a near-total loss of credibility of the government by private business. Those in charge of Etihad Airlines must be wondering why they decided to put their money in a country as poorly run as India. Hopefully, the coming elections will result in a change such that efficiency and direction returns to the processes of governance. Should that happen, investment from Abu Dhabi (the country which owns Etihad) can reach $200 billion, such is the enormous potential in India for investment from the GCC, a part of the world which is culturally and historically close to India. Add another $300 billion from East Asia, and the picture now presented would become totally different. However, all this remains hypothetical. For now, India remains in effect what it has been for centuries, a colony of more canny players.

http://pakobserver.net/detailnews.asp?id=211713

Drop double standards (China Daily)

By M. D. Nalapat

The brutality of the recent attacks on innocent civilians in the Xinjiang Uygur autonomous region proves that the rioters were terrorists rather than "heroes", as the Western media at times prefer to call them.
The brutal tactics used by the rioters in Xinjiang is typical of terrorists, who believe in "shock and awe" to stun their foes into accepting their demands. There is no place in a civilized society for violence, and this is the principal reason why the international community should unitedly fight against terrorists.
In the latest Xinjiang riots, 24 people, including 16 innocent Uygurs, were killed in Lukqun township of Shanshan county. The rioters attacked the township's police stations, a local government building and a construction site, and set fire to police cars. Twenty-one police officers and civilians were injured.
Such atrocities should be condemned by all but sadly, such unity of purpose against this deadly foe of civilization is absent in the international community.
Islam is a religion with varied sects. Like other religions, it also has its share of moderates and fundamentalists. And it is these fundamentalist (or extreme) elements that have unleashed terror on the better part of the globe. Their trail of terror runs from Afghanistan, Pakistan, China, India, Russia and Thailand to Nigeria, Algeria and Mali. In fact, no country seems to be immune to terrorist attacks, although the West continues to use double standards to determine such attacks in its own backyard and in countries like China.
Islamic fundamentalists believe believers in other religions (or even other Islamic sects) are "infidels" and thus not fit to live. They detest modern society, especially the advancement made by women. It is by getting access to such fundamental religious texts that some people in Xinjiang have acquired extremist beliefs, including the penchant for violence.
NATO member states, in particular, have been known for their partnership with such extremists, most recently in Libya and Syria, where extremist groups have been armed and set loose against the rest of society. Former Libyan president Muammar Gadhafi was indeed a whimsical leader. But throughout his years in power he ensured that Libya remained free of Islamic extremists. In contrast, after its "liberation" by NATO, Libya has become a honeycomb of terror cells and a prolific source of weapons, men and materials for terrorist groups operating in Africa, most visibly in Mali.
In Syria, Jabhat al-Nusra is in control of the rebel groups fighting to overthrow the Syrian government, although its operatives now function under different labels after the US branded it a terrorist group. Jabhat al-Nusra, however, has not had any difficulty in coordinating its activities or in enforcing the brutal logic of Islamic extremism in the Syrian conflict, such as the recent beheading of three Christians and the forced evacuation of Christians, Druze and Shias from the areas controlled by this NATO-supported band of thugs.
Interestingly, neither the United States nor the European Union has even noticed that in Homs, al-Qusayr, Aleppo and other cities temporarily occupied by the Free Syrian Army (a camouflage for Jabhat al-Nusra), Christians, Druze and Shias have been either killed or driven out, with many of their women becoming trophies of war.
Throughout the 1990s, former US president Bill Clinton supported the extremists operating in India and Afghanistan. But for the backing given by the US, the Taliban would never have succeeded to seize power in Afghanistan in 1996. The same set of "expert advisers" who orchestrated that takeover are still present in force in think tanks, government departments and intelligence agencies in Washington, so it is little wonder that they are seeking to bring the Taliban back into the Afghanistan government. The Taliban have even been gifted a multi-million dollar building as well as SUVs and huge amounts of cash in Qatar.
Until NATO understands that terrorism is a threat in its entirety, and that it needs to be opposed everywhere rather than just in the West, the world will not be free of this scourge. It is ironical to see France, which doesn't allow Muslim women to even use veils to cover their faces, trying to push a band of extreme elements led by Jabhat al-Nusra to power in Syria through the help of the gun.
Such double standards will finally boomerang on France, for after assuming power in Damascus, the extremists will set their sights on Paris, London and other Western cities (if not to seize power then to create terror) using Syria as a base in the same way they are using Libya now.
Chinese people have come face to face with extremist terror, and understand the need to build a joint front to fight this evil. So China should join hands with its neighbors to work out a comprehensive strategy against extremist terror. The problem can be solved only if the international community ensures that terrorists don't get shelter and encouragement from anyone.
And it's high time the US-led West realized that by dancing with extremists in theaters like Syria it is placing its own people at the risk of further terrorist attacks.
The author is vice-chair of Manipal Advanced Research Group and UNESCO peace chair, and professor of geopolitics at Manipal University, India.
(China Daily 07/04/2013 page9)

Thursday, 4 July 2013

Why Morsi is wrong for his people (Gateway House)


DIRECTOR, DEPARTMENT OF GEOPOLITICS, MANIPAL UNIVERSITY

History is peppered with situations in which a small group of individuals took control of a broad movement and over time, subverted and distorted it in order to fit society within the straitjacket of their views.
In 1917, the Bolshevik Party led by Vladimir Lenin was a group with support only within the fringes of Russian society, yet it was able to seize control of the state and destroy the liberal promise of the Alexander Kerensky period. The latter made the fatal error of underestimating his people’s exhaustion with World War I, thereby dooming it by refusing to sue for peace which, later, the more prescient Lenin did, to opposition from much of his own party. Later, in 1933, a group of conservatives believed that they could leash Adolf Hitler and his National Socialist German Workers Party or NSDAP to their purposes, only to get swept away within a year.
Fast forward to 1979,when the group of zealots who originated the theology of Khomeinism grabbed control of a protest movement against the Shah of Iran and brought into being a “mullahcracy” which has stifled a great nation ever since.
Although the beneficiaries of the “Arab Spring” will bristle at the comparison, the reality is that the power grab of the Wahabbist elements – which go by the title of the “Muslim Brotherhood” – took control of Egypt, Libya and Tunisia in the same way as Ayatollah Khomeini’s followers did their country, i.e. by taking advantage of a broad-based protest movement to seize control of the organs of the state. Over a century, Wahabbis have been successful in cloaking themselves in the glorious flag of the Islamic faith, thereby portraying support for them as fealty to the faith. They have done this in much the same way as a certain class of politicians uses their national flag and its patriotic spirit to enter into foreign adventures that are in reality damaging to the national interest.
Despite its (numerous) faults, Ottoman society had a broadly syncretic view of the world, such that people of multiple faiths lived, played and worked together in those locations under the sway of the Ottoman sultans and the distinctive green flag they popularised. In contrast, the Wahabbis have an exclusivist, religious supremacist view of themselves and the rest of the world. In those countries dominated by Wahabbi impulses, from mild (Malaysia) to full-blown (such as the Taliban-controlled parts of Afghanistan), those not subscribing to the viewpoint of this three-century-old theology are subject to multiple forms of discrimination. In Malaysia, products that are not certified as “halal” are banned from supermarket shelves, even though more than 40% of the population is non-Muslim. The majority of even the Muslim population follows the syncretic version of the faith still practiced in nearby Java rather than the austere version followed in Saudi Arabia, a country that has imposed multiple restrictions on women, Shia, minority faiths and non-Wahabbi Sunnis.
There are conservative, exclusivist groups within every faith, including Buddhism, Judaism, Christianity and Hinduism. Yet it is only in the case of Islam that the West-or in a more accurate shorthand the NATO bloc – persists in identifying such groups as representative of the entire Muslim Ummah, when in fact the people following that faith have the same moderate chemistry and goals as those from other faiths. So successful have the Wahabbis been in cloaking themselves in the raiment of the great faith revealed to the Prophet Mohammad 15 centuries ago, that Wahabbism and Islam are usually seen as identical, whereas in fact they are not twins but antipodes.
The Holy Quran is suffused with the message of beneficence, mercy and compassion in contrast to the unforgiving, self-obsessed path followed by the Wahabbi. Indeed, it may be argued that the very term “Muslim Brotherhood” is a negation of the universal message of the Holy Quran, which revealed that all life sprang from the same Almighty force. Those who believe in exclusivism go against the central message of the universality of God. The very life of Prophet Mohammad is replete not with war and vengeance, but with consistent acts of forgiveness and mercy, even to those who had grievously wronged him in the past. The interludes of battle were usually short and few, whereas the phases of peace were many and long. This situation contrasts with the incessant war, declared or undeclared, covert or overt, waged by Wahabbi groups against “The Other.”
Fortunately, the overwhelming majority of Muslims, including those living inWahabbized states, subscribe to the liberal – and correct – definition of Islam.
Unfortunately, this majority is not taken by those of other faiths as representative of themselves. Rather, the fringe, comprising of those who follow Wahabbi theology, is taken as representing the whole, to the overall detriment of the global community.
Mohammad Morsi is the direct descendant of the theological DNA created by Seyyid Qutub – who was executed for plotting the assassination of Egyptian President Gamal Nasser in 1966 – who saw human society in terms of “Us” and “Them”. Rather than encourage Muslims to go into the world and learn from others, thereby  competing with the rest, Qutub sought to scare them away from contact with those not of a Wahabbi persuasion. He created a ghettoisation that had a deleterious impact on relations between communities. The onset of Wahabbism across the globe since the 1980s has led to a revival of ritual and externalities at the cost of the inner discovery that is the essence of Jihad. Among the great gifts of Islam to the primitive society whence it was revealed, was the increased status of women as not seen before. This is contrary to the discrimination seen in today’s Wahabbized societies.
By – in practice – limiting the concept of Brotherhood not to the entire Ummah but only to Wahabbis, the parties that have exploited the “Arab Spring” to take office in Libya, Tunisia and Egypt and its cousin in Turkey, are embracing a vision at odds with the universality of their faith.
Morsi and ErdoÄŸan have focused on persecuting those who refuse to share their vision, a stance which has led to the unrest against such repression. Should the protestors at Tahrir Square and at Taksim Square succeed in turfing from office regimes that have turned their backs on the humane essence which is Islam, the process will mark the beginning of the Reformation that will, when completed, herald the return of the Ummah to the vanguard of human progress.
Given the affinity of its foreign and defense policy establishment for Wahabbism, it is certain that the Obama administration will seek to get the Egyptian military to roll back its push for a more inclusive system of governance than the “Brotherhood Takes All” model of Morsi. This will be a mistake. The fall of Wahabbi regimes will be the true revolution, just as the takeover of state power by the Wahabbis following the unrest of 2011 was a subversion of the zeitgeist of those times.
Morsi cannot make history, nor can ErdoÄŸan. They need to become history, and the Ummah rescued from its false champions. The era of Seyyid Qutub must end, and the hundreds of thousands in Tahrir and Taksim have begun the process of integrating their countries into the overall societal fabric of the globe.

Monday, 1 July 2013

Forget economic dictatorship, try democracy instead (Sunday Guardian)


Mamata Banerjee and JD(U) general secretary K.C. Tyagi address media on the Federal Front in Kolkata on 12 June. PTI
reat minds across the globe celebrate India as a democracy, despite the reality of the British colonial system of law and administration continuing in the country to this date. It was their refusal to cede even a modicum of control of institutions other than those controlled by themselves, that saw Jawaharlal Nehru and Indira Gandhi presiding over a country that grew by less than 3% annually at a time when even Pakistan was developing twice as fast, and only Mao's China was comparable in its sluggish path.
Since the Great Helmsman passed on to his creator, Beijing has changed considerably, in the process ensuring that at least in the field of business, there is far greater scope for innovation and decentralisation in the Chinese economy than in our own. In India, almost every key decision needs to get prior approval by Central authorities, leaving very little discretion to other levels of governance. The potential of such a top-down system for generating bribes is what has prevented successive regimes from creating a more democratic framework for governance, one that would devolve power to levels lower than Delhi.
Indeed, so stifling is the domination of the national capital over the country's life that it could well be said that India is a colony of Delhi, or at least that part of it with well-manicured lawns, uninterrupted power and water supplies, and bungalows vacated by the British that were occupied in a trice by their native inheritors. If China has developed so rapidly since Deng Xiaoping got full control of the Chinese Communist Party by 1981, the reason is that he ensured that even a city mayor could take decisions relating to economic and business matters in a way that even a state Chief Minister cannot in India.
This columnist has had several meetings — in the 1980s and mostly at the Bangalore home of Ramakrishna Hegde — with Biju Patnaik but has yet to meet his son Naveen. However, newspapers say that the current Chief Minister of Orissa, in tandem with his counterparts in Bengal and Tamil Nadu, are exploring the formation of a "federal front". Why not an "economic democracy" front, that calls for devolving authority not just to state capitals but even lower down, to cities and panchayats? Why not allow each such unit substantial latitude in what it offers to business and individuals to locate there, so that competition may get engendered?
Manmohan Singh made the correct call in leaving to the state governments the decision on whether to welcome foreign retail chains or not. The BJP was wrong in going against Atal Behari Vajpayee and seeking a blockade on all such investment everywhere in India, thereby moving closer to the Left parties, who are still in the era of Mao Zedong rather than having moved to that of Deng Xiaoping. This "economic democracy front" (or "democracy front" in brief, seeing that economics plays such a huge role in our lives) could demand devolution of financial and other powers down the administrative chain, until the lowest level. After the polls, it could align with that party, whether Congress or BJP, that was most likely to implement the reforms needed to ensure that mayors in India get the same powers as their counterparts in China.
This columnist has for close to two years argued that there are two attractive leaders who have emerged in India, and that these are Narendra Modi and Rahul Gandhi. He has met the Gujarat CM a few times but the Congress party vice-president has this far remained elusive, possibly owing to a natural — and fetching — shyness. Both need to work on a model of economic governance that is far removed from the overcentralised version that has been in vogue in India since the Mughal period. Over the course of the next six months, both Narendra Modi as well as Rahul Gandhi ought to articulate their New Economic Policy over the coming months, so that those political parties eager for a break from a Delhi-centric regimen will know just who among the pair will be the better partner in order to actualise their vision.
The country needs full democracy, not simply a chance to cast one's ballot every few years to elect a candidate from within a listless list of durbari politicians chosen for reasons of personal loyalty rather than
administrative ability, and it is time for Naveen Patnaik, Jayalalithaa and Mamata to work out a blueprint for change that would become the precondition for a future alliance with that party or alliance that shows the better promise about being sincere about change.